PTT評價

Re: [爆卦] 柴可夫斯基被禁了

看板Gossiping標題Re: [爆卦] 柴可夫斯基被禁了作者
arrenwu
(不是綿芽的錯)
時間推噓 6 推:6 噓:0 →:11

※ 引述《pinebox (pinebox)》之銘言:
: 好像還沒人貼。
: https://bit.ly/3vUUmGb
: (Newsweek) Orchestras Pull Tchaikovsky From Concerts Over Russia's War on Ukraine
: 威爾斯卡地夫愛樂管弦樂團,將柴可夫斯基曲目移出。
: 我朋友說原因是吃飽太閒。
: 他錯了。
: 原因是普丁壞壞,俄國入侵烏克蘭。
: 日本也有樂團共襄盛舉,踢掉柴可夫斯基。
: 不要以為死了一百多年就沒事。
: 開棺曝屍,鞭數十,驅之別院。
: 下去跟杜斯鴕鳥夫斯基作伴吧。
: https://i.imgur.com/9woGxDQ.jpg


官網有個很平淡的聲明
https://www.cardiffphilharmonic.com/future-concerts

不管官網還是Newsweek的報導,我看到的部分所提及的是將1812序曲移除表演名單

On Wednesday, Wales' Cardiff Philharmonic Orchestra announced it would be
removing Tchaikovsky's "1812 Overture" from a March 18 concert.


而 Newsweek 那篇報導裡面有說明更多原因:

The "1812 Overture" was written to celebrate Russia's defense against the
invasion of Napoleon, and is notable for featuring a barrage of cannon fire
in its composition.

1812 序曲原本是為了慶祝俄羅斯成功抵抗拿破崙入侵所創作的。
其中一個著名特色是會配合砲聲


The director for the orchestra, Martin May, told Newsweek, "The decision on
this concert was very much based on here and now. A member of the orchestra
has family directly involved in the Ukraine situation and we are trying to
respect that situation during the immediate term. There were also two
military themed pieces as part of the programme (Marche Slave and 1812) that
we felt were particularly inappropriate at this time."

樂團總監 Martin May 表示

"這是基於現況所做的決定"

"有一個樂團成員他的家庭正直接在烏克蘭受影響,所以我們想短期間應對這情況"

"我們覺得有兩首跟部隊主題相關的曲目(Marche Slave 和 1812)現在並不合適"


(哇 Marche Slave 被移除真是可惜了 我覺得這首非常好聽!)

May added that another piece of Tchaikovsky's "Symphony No. 2," titled
"Little Russian," was deemed offensive to Ukrainians. There are currently no
plans to change any of the summer and autumn concerts featuring other Russiancomposers. "This is a one off decision made with the best of intentions," he
said.

May還說柴可夫斯基的一首標題名為 Little Russian 的二號交響曲也被認為對
烏克蘭人非常有冒犯性。目前沒有改動夏季和秋季演奏會中跟其他俄羅斯作曲家創作
有關的部分。

"這個是個出於善意的暫時性措施"


--
角卷綿芽二周年紀念套組
https://i.imgur.com/5iPOx4p.jpg

開放預購至 台灣時間2022年01月31日下午5:00 止
官方連結:https://shop.hololivepro.com/products/tsunomakiwatame_an2nd

--

※ PTT 留言評論
※ 發信站: 批踢踢實業坊(ptt.cc), 來自: 98.45.135.233 (美國)
PTT 網址

cuteSquirrel 03/10 22:37洋洋終於上線了!!

heavensun 03/10 22:37芭蕾 天鵝湖 不能跳惹?

clover1211 03/10 22:40無聊喔 = =

jinx5566 03/10 22:40假道學 笑死

raku 03/10 22:44左膠zzzzzzzzzzzz

rommel1 03/10 22:491812序曲 慶祝俄國擊敗拿破崙

c98406023 03/10 22:53西方國家進入戒嚴時代,詞曲審查

tchaikov1812 03/10 23:001812序曲是歌頌衛國者抵抗並擊敗以

tchaikov1812 03/10 23:00大義為名的侵略者,現在不正適合給

tchaikov1812 03/10 23:00予烏克蘭嗎

ID正確!

※ 編輯: arrenwu (98.45.135.233 美國), 03/10/2022 23:00:44

tchaikov1812 03/10 23:20建議可以把馬賽曲那段改成現代俄羅

tchaikov1812 03/10 23:20斯國歌

froheprinz 03/11 11:30Little Russian是在烏克蘭創作的,不

froheprinz 03/11 11:30過我不知道為什麼有冒犯性,因為我只

froheprinz 03/11 11:30聽過第五、六號交響曲

froheprinz 03/13 16:49我自己找到答案了

froheprinz 03/13 16:49 https://i.imgur.com/InnZoke.jpg