PTT評價

Re: [討論] 油車火燒車

看板car標題Re: [討論] 油車火燒車作者
jemdogdog
(極度深寒)
時間推噓 8 推:9 噓:1 →:6

※ 引述《SCkevin (逃跑計畫)》之銘言:
: 林志穎 特斯拉Model X火燒車今天吵的沸沸揚揚
: 隨手YouTube查一下火燒車的新聞,時間設定這個月結果一大堆,為啥油車火燒車都沒人要關心啊
: 還是大家早習慣了
: https://i.imgur.com/Zb64Keh.jpg

: https://i.imgur.com/jhrZ3s2.jpg
: https://i.imgur.com/UvfMiMs.jpg
: -----
: Sent from JPTT on my iPhone

一分證據一分話
隨便google 一下
關鍵字: ICE car EV fire accident mortality

Do Electric Cars Catch Fire More Than Gas-Powered Vehicles?

https://reurl.cc/GEZ4mA

A recent study from insurance experts AutoinsuranceEZ.com might have some
answers. Researchers posed the question, “Are electric vehicles more prone
to car fires than gas or hybrid vehicles?” Using data collected and analyzed
from sources including the National Transportation Safety Board (NTSB),
Bureau of Transportation Statistics (BTS), and government recall data from
Recalls.gov, researchers broke down incidents of car fires by vehicle and
fuel type.

Hybrid vehicles: 3,474 fires per 100K sales
Gas vehicles: 1,529 fires per 100K sales
Electric vehicles: 25 fires per 100K sales

但是文章也提到

Although electric vehicles (EVs) may not catch fire as often as other
vehicles, when they do catch fire, they can be extremely difficult to
extinguish and cause much more damage. This has to do with the battery, whichwe’ll talk about more in a moment.

結論是
電車比油車著火的機率少很多倍 (大概1:60)
但是救火難度高了N倍


--
支那人沒有一個是無辜的

--

※ PTT 留言評論
※ 發信站: 批踢踢實業坊(ptt.cc), 來自: 39.9.205.0 (臺灣)
PTT 網址
※ 編輯: jemdogdog (39.9.205.0 臺灣), 07/22/2022 18:20:08

joiedevivre 07/22 18:20有沒有考慮車齡的統計?

william826 07/22 18:20還是國產giant最安全又健康

winwillyc 07/22 18:24我覺得分母用銷售量不太好,因為使用客群、車齡等

winwillyc 07/22 18:24等都沒考慮進去

cofejt 07/22 18:24結論騙人,因為今天的火燒車看起來就車速不快

kissa092430707/22 18:25騎腳踏車就沒這問題啦

ingmu 07/22 18:26噓的不懂機率的意思? 笑死

winwillyc 07/22 18:28我覺得油車還有一大部分是因為漏油沒檢查開一開燒起

winwillyc 07/22 18:29來,應該要研究在事故的當下起火大比例

qscgg 07/22 18:57有沒有火災傷亡人數統計?感覺電車燒了很難跑

tokyoto 07/22 21:15它那是統計結果不是預測結果 用"比率"會比"機率"精

tokyoto 07/22 21:16確一點 但因為電車都還很新 老車的問題還沒浮現 還

tokyoto 07/22 21:17要多看幾年才能有比較客觀的結論

ISNAKEI 07/22 21:45用銷售比怪怪的 油車很多跑二十年了

SiriusJinn 07/23 00:34說高科技的電車,淪落到跟油車比爛XD

kusomanfcu 07/23 10:23電車就是簡單,不是沒事就是直接往生